Nuclear war cannot be won, so we have to at least keep talking.
When I made my first public suggestion for cooperation between the United States, Russia and China it was an unpopular thing to do. During a Jeffersonian Dinner in 2023, I proposed hosting a dinner using the symbolism of my grandfather, Robert Oppenheimer, to bring together then President Joe Biden, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping to discuss reducing nuclear risks. The host responded: “Wow—you are going against the only bipartisan agreement: being against China and Russia!”
It is not about being anti-China and Russia, it is about being pro-peace. Living under the constant threat of nuclear armageddon, regardless of who the bombs belong to, is not peace but the sustainment of antagonism. Agreements to eliminate the danger these weapons pose are pro-peace.
This was my grandfather’s recommendation in 1946. He believed that cooperation between the United States and the Soviet Union, specifically on the management of atomic science and technology, could have prevented an arms race and helped to lower the pressures for great power competition. Now, 80 years later, the same opportunity is in front of us.
Most of the coverage on this summit has followed a similar line: ‘We disagree with your actions, therefore we will punish you by refusing to talk.’
But when we are dealing with the most important issue in the world, the survival of humanity, we need more dialogue between the countries with the greatest capacity to cause harm or pursue peace, particularly at the leadership level.
That is what just occurred in Shenzhen, China between President Donald Trump and his Chinese and Russian counterparts. They did not establish concrete policy goals or solve the underlying problems. But they echoed the principle that has been central to nuclear arms control for decades: “Nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought,” and agreed to “conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.”
The work to reduce those risks has been underway for decades and may take decades more, but they are still necessary. This is precisely why we need nongovernmental organizations, think tanks, policy experts, and advocates to help continue the work of putting real policies on the table – because leaders change but the threat of nuclear war remains.
I support this effort, including its symbolism and the recognition that cooperation does not require agreement on everything, and have been vocal about it in public and private. Now I am going to double down on my efforts through a new initiative: the Oppenheimer Prize. Please contact us if you are interested in hearing more about that idea!